A Comment on the Ratio of the Maximum and Minimum Dry Density for Sand

Geotechnical Engineering Journal of the SEAGS & AGSSEA ISSN 0046-5828

Vol. 42 No.4 December 2011

A Comment on the Ratio of the Maximum and Minimum Dry Density for Sand

E. Imre, S. Fityus, E. Keszeyne and T. Schanz

ABSTRACT: This work reveals an interesting feature of sand behaviour: the ratio of the minimum and the maximum dry density, D, is about constant. This statement is discussed here on the basis of the analysis of two databases: the database of the “Calibration Chamber” sands and the database of the Danube sands. Results show that although the D values are significantly and systematically different for the Calibration Chamber sands and the Danube sands, the coefficients of variation of the D values for each sample population is very small in each case. The difference in the characteristic D values in each case is explained in terms of differences in the experimental methods used and differences in the geological origin of the soils.

KEYWORDS: A Comment, Ratio Of The Maximum, Minimum, Dry Density, Sands

DOI: 10.14456/seagj.2011.9